Monday, April 22, 2013

An interview worth reading


What is so special about this interview.?

 There are two things. First is the way in which Mr Tarek Fatah replies. A person who is visiting India for the first time understands what exactly  is going on here as far as so called secular politics is concerned. He refused to entertain the stories of so called 'persecution of Muslims' And 'Hindu fascism.' He advices Indian Muslims to be an integral part of Indian culture.

Second special thing is 'the interviewer' Times of India's journalist is trying to put some words in Mr Fatah's mouth like -' rise of Right wing Hindutava fascism', ........' Muslims being maimed in communal riots, persecuted for being Muslims and discriminated against by Hindus'.............'But serious questions remain in India about Muslims being discriminated against '...............'because India has caused Kashmiri Muslims graver political injustice. No?'............. and when she finds that Mr Fatah is not falling into the trap then she attacks him -"Are you a self-hating Muslim?" ...

This is one of  the basic ideas of secularism  . If someone is a Muslim and he is not blaming India,  or  weeping for injustice to Kashmir and is not cursing the  so called Hindu extremism .... then he is a 'self hating Muslim.

She is certain about ' rise of Right wing Hindutava fascism' but she asks  'Does India really have an Islamo-fascism problem?'.....Well done Aarti Tikoo Singh. 
Well done 'The Times of India'

Tarek Fatah: India is the only country where Muslims exert influence without fear

Aarti Tikoo Singh | Apr 19, 2013, 12.00 AM IST

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/opinion/interviews/Tarek-Fatah-India-is-the-only-country-where-Muslims-exert-influence-without-fear/articleshow/19619612.cms

"India does have an Islamo-fascism problem."

" Why would Muslim parents not name their children after indigenous Indian names? Why do they have to constantly borrow from the Arabs or the Persians?"


"If Muslim women cannot go to a mosque and sit in the front row, it is not a Hindu problem."

"Indian Muslims have the Islamo-fascists feeding on the culture of victimhood who do not want it to be solved. If the discrimination that they perceive ends then the Islamo-fascists have no fodder to feed on. So they want to make it worse for the Muslims by telling them not to integrate."


" I as a Muslim should today have rights that would have saved Mansur al- Hallaj from a torturous death in the tenth century. His body was ripped apart and his limbs were amputated because he said, 'Ana al-Haqq' (I am the light)."

Tarek Fatah: India is the only country where Muslims exert influence without fear

As a Muslim, i found it fascinating that India only place in the world where Muslims exert influence without fear.

 

Tarek Fatah is a Canadian writer and advocate of a progressive and liberal Muslim identity. Speaking with Aarti Tikoo Singh, Fatah discussed his emphasis on Muslims fighting tyranny, why left-wing groups are often wrong in assessing Islamic movements — and how Indian Muslims are uniquely placed to challenge repression:

You're visiting India for the first time — what are your impressions?

I'm relieved all my impressions turned out to be realistic — India is the only country offering a future in terms of what the nation state would be and how to accommodate languages, races and religions with all the difficulties that go with that. As a Muslim, i found it fascinating that this is the only place in the world where Muslims exert influence without fear. Muslims are better equipped in India than in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
You lead a secular reformist movement for Muslims — did you find support from Indian liberals?

I think they're puzzled. I felt the vast majority of Indian Muslims are open to the idea of a separation of religion and state. They've rejected Islamic states, voting to stay here — however, there is no leadership in the Muslim community that says, 'Not in my name'. I talked to prominent Muslims who said, "You're not going to make me deal with issues as a Muslim. I am an Indian. " But i feel they are abdicating the responsibility they have, as the only Muslims with the freedom to stand up against those who wish to take this freedom away.

Actually, liberals across the world have abdicated this responsibility, indulging in what i call left-wing Orientalism. Islamo-fascism is not the result of economic deprivation. It is an ideological war, based on a death cult — you can't use conventional socio-political wisdom to address this.

Unfortunately, the liberal Left, including socialist parties in America and India, doesn't admit they don't have it right. But they're making an error in thinking Islamo-fascism is linked with economic deprivation. Such thinkers should go on a sabbatical to Syria, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Aligarh — they'd be in for the shock of their lives.


But serious questions remain in India about Muslims being discriminated against — isn't that of concern?

I don't deny that — but i would rather live with discrimination, where i have the right to speak out, than live somewhere women and others are targeted in the name of Islam. Of course there's oppression in India too against women but nobody says it's an act of piety — it's 'dadagiri', not piety. It can be corrected with better enforcement of laws offering equality and protection. In the Islamic world, the law itself says women are inferior to men.

Indian Muslims have a good thing going — but if you're not ensuring, for instance, that every girl is educated, you're making sure things don't become as good as they could be. It is the responsibility of liberal Muslims to discuss issues and say this or that is not acceptable. If Muslim women cannot go to a mosque and sit in the front row, it is not a Hindu problem. If Muslim men don't treat female relations with equal dignity, why are they complaining that others aren't doing so?

The onus is on us. You can't fight fascism batting on the back foot. You've got to hit it out of the park.

I put harsher responsibility on Indian Muslims because they are free, living in a democratic society. If they want to know what it's like to live under Islamic rule, they can see what`s happening in Pakistan.
_______________________________________________
The above interview appeared in the print edition. The rest of the interview is exclusive to the web edition of The Times of India.

Q: You were scheduled to talk at Jamia Milia Islamia, New Delhi, but the event was canceled for some reason. What happened?

I blame the handful of people who exerted pressure but these people don't realize that by stifling my opinion, they made it go viral in an era of Twitter and Facebook. So I am not angry; I am just saddened by the religious Right of the Muslim community.

This is not a reflection on the Indian Muslims. Most Muslims I have met here or talked to, whether it is Irfan Habib or Javed Akhtar, were appalled. But what happened at Jamia Milia is contemporary reaction even in the US, Britain, France where very few people are willing to challenge the Islamist discourse for fear of being dubbed as anti-Islam or Islamophobic.

Q: Does India really have an Islamo-fascism problem? Isn't the problem in India primarily about Muslims being maimed in communal riots, persecuted for being Muslims and discriminated against by Hindus?

First of all, India does have an Islamo-fascism problem. Otherwise why would the Jamia event get canceled despite the fact that it is a university led by a very leading intellectual in the Indian Muslim community? SIMI is not Made-In-Japan institution; it is indigenous to India. The Dukhtaran-e-Millat Kashmir fascists, the acid-throwing anarchists are indigenous to India. These are Muslim extremists. The Owaisi brothers have not been imported from Singapore; they are indigenous to Hyderabad.

Indian Muslims have the Islamo-fascists feeding on the culture of victimhood who do not want it to be solved. If the discrimination that they perceive ends then the Islamo-fascists have no fodder to feed on. So they want to make it worse for the Muslims by telling them not to integrate. I would ask a question: Why would Muslim parents not name their children after indigenous Indian names? Why do they have to constantly borrow from the Arabs or the Persians?

Q: India is struggling with various separatist violent movements in Kashmir, Northeast, Maoist bastions and the rise of Right wing Hindutava fascism. Aren't they as worrisome as Islamo-fascism?

These movements within India can't be compared to Islamo-fascism. They are their own problems that are being addressed wrongly. The solution to these problems lies through democracy and not by taking up arms in a democratic state. If you are under a dictatorial regime, then I would support the taking up of arms. I support the Baloch guerillas for taking up arms in a country that is run by a military. But this is a democracy. You have to be patient in a democracy. Muslims adhering to Islamo-fascism and having the Left support it is a different issue.

Q: Is your fight against Islamo-fascism relevant to India where secularism is understood and practiced very differently from what it is in the West? The Indian law does not permit criticism that offends religious sentiment.

The very notion of Western law and all our civilization is based on European reaffirmation and anyone who suggests India's democracy is its own development is not telling the truth. The concept of a secret vote has stemmed from the French and American revolutions and the British coming to this part of the country, otherwise you would have, at best, the panchayat system. If the constitution does not say that you can't offend, then the constitution should say that you have the right to offend. You don't have the right to cause harm to a third person, but you should have the absolute right to have an opinion on any dogma, religious belief, on anything and express it.

Many of the founding fathers or mothers of India were atheists. They mocked every religion. You can't be a member of the Communist Party and say well, I can't offend religion. Your existence is an offense to Christianity, Hinduism, Islam and Judaism. Anyone who has been a member of the Communist Party and is an atheist is de facto saying 'I don't believe in this nonsense'. So already you have determined that it is ok to offend. Otherwise the Communist Party of India would be banned. They have a 75-year-old history in this country. They are part and parcel of the independence movement of Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, India and Nepal. So if you take away the right to offend another religion, then let us put all the communists behind bars.

I think India has a bright future, because no civilization has moved backwards. It is a scientific fact and this is based on history that the future is of societies where culture and custom play a secondary role to parliaments and legislatures. It ought not to be the other way. That is the nature of the ideal nation-state. We pass laws knowing that laws would be changed by future generations and thus improved upon, but we don't have religious dogma that can be changed by a future generation. Whether it is the Old Testament or the Quran or the Gita, there is no version 2.1 coming out.

We have a choice- We protect our traditions because it is offensive to challenge them, and live as tribals following hierarchical or patriarchal societies, where the rights of women or minorities are a matter of tradition, OR we can build towards the society where traditions do not constrain us from building the ideal society, where men and women are equal, Black and White is equal and Hindu and Muslim is equal. But if you cannot push the notion that you cannot criticize a religion or its followers, then there is no democracy, then there is no free speech. I as a Muslim should today have rights that would have saved Mansur al- Hallaj from a torturous death in the tenth century. His body was ripped apart and his limbs were amputated because he said, 'Ana al-Haqq' (I am the light). He was the first Muslim atheist to have died when the Caliph begged him 'come on, you know, I am an atheist, you know that, let us make a compromise'. He said 'no, I would rather die than lie'. So people who are nonbelievers in any faith have as much a right to state their case.

Q: Do you share the same optimism for India's neighbors, that is Bangladesh and Pakistan where you were born and raised?

Pakistan will soon disintegrate. Pakistan is not a country. It is an idea. If you want to know what Pakistan is, then you go to Dhaka, not to Islamabad. None of the territories that comprise Pakistan today, had anything to do with Pakistan. The NWFP was governed by the Congress party. In the Punjab the Muslim League didn't win power. In Sindh they didn't get power, Balochistan was an independent state that Pakistan occupied with the military invasion, in Kashmir which Pakistan claims, Sheikh Abdullah had nothing to do with the type of thuggery that Mohammad Ali Jinnah was doing. And you go everywhere along the route, the only people that wanted Pakistan were the UPites, Biharis, north Indian Hindi belt Muslims who migrated to Karachi. And then they built Pakistan into a society that ruled us like colonial rulers. They destroyed and devastated the languages and cultures indigenous to the people of Pakistan and imposed Urdu on them and then made the entire Punjab Muslim community deny its own language by banning it from official institutions. So today, we have the result that in the Punjab assembly, you are not allowed to speak in Punjabi.

It is a dismal case of pan-Islamism, that has been an experiment which failed in 1971. It failed much earlier in fact, because people after people, regime after regime invoked pan-Islamism to kill Muslims. So forget about Pakistan. At some stage, it will wither away. At some stage, Balochistan has to secede. It is the fifth civil war they are fighting against the Pakistani military. The Pakistani military is an industrial mafia that controls everything from cereals to trucks to missiles to magazines to banks. It is the most vivid example of what President Roosevelt talked about the military-industrial complex.

Bangladesh, on the other hand, is an incredibly exciting place to be because that is where the Muslim vs the Islamist fight is taking place. You've got Islamists on one hand demanding the death penalty against anyone who is an atheist, and on the other bloggers who are less organized, have a bigger popular base but are naively saying that they are nonpolitical. Reminds me of Mao Tse Tung's ' a single spark can launch a prairie fire.' The bloggers have done that, so this fight is going there and my feeling is that even if they lose, the Shahbhag movement will in the end, succeed. As with other Muslim countries though, it is possible that any mediocrity on the part of leadership may have serious consequences. It is reflected in Syria and Egypt where despite the revolutions, things have gone worse.

Q: You are working on your third book, 'Jinnah's Orphans'. Can you please explain the title?

The current tragedy of the Indian subcontinent is a direct result of Mohd. Ali Jinnah's absurd philosophy of the Two Nation Theory and his refusal to compromise with Gandhi or Nehru and his complete adherence to the dictates of the Anglo-American enterprise which wanted Pakistan created because they saw that in a united India, they won't be able to get air force bases in the Himalayas where they were peeping right over the mountain tips to the Red Army which had entered Iran and set up the Kurdish republic and the Azheri republic. They also had King Zahir Shah who was a supporter of the Soviets.

And you have to understand that the Baloch, who were separate, were also led by Mir Bizenjo who was a member of the Communist Party of India, Khair Bhaksh Marri who was also an Oxford Communist, and vast cadres of Left wing activists that drove the fear into the heart of Americans. So Pakistan was created primarily as a consequence by utilizing Islam to fight communism on the backs of ordinary Indian Muslims. No other Muslim people have been used like fodder like the northern Indian Muslim or the Pakistani Muslim, even the Bangladeshi Muslim. Hence Jinnah's Orphans!

I am going to Dhaka and look at one million stateless people, the Biharis, who do not wish to be Bangladeshi, do not wish to be Indian, do not wish to be Pakistani and none of these countries want them. They are the quintessential orphans- the most vivid example of the tragedy that nobody wants to even resolve. But they are not the only ones. The three million dead Bangladeshis are also the orphans. Bangladeshis, the Khalistan movement, Pakistan's troubles, Balochistan's civil war, the bleeding issue of Kashmir since 1965, is a direct result of Jinnah's Two Nation Theory. Every victim of the Kashmir violence, whether it is the Kashmiri Pandits or the Kashmiri Muslims, the Chinese taking over Baltistan, the Pakistan Army destroying all Kashmiri culture and imposing Urdu and Punjabi over there- All these tragedies, I refer to as Jinnah's Orphans. The reason I am writing is that I haven't seen any non-fiction literature that has a composite view of what has happened as a result of Jinnah's Two Nation Theory.

Q: Why do you blame only Jinnah?

Nehru and Gandhi are guilty of giving in to Jinnah. Jinnah is the instrument. With Gandhi and Nehru, my beef is that they betrayed Badshah Khan. They left him to the dogs. Badshah Khan delivered the North Western Frontier Province to the Congress. Then Sardar Patel and Nehru in their wisdom decided that the Pashtun Indians were not worthy of being looked after and they suffered. And the Bengalis suffered because of that decision. So the blame is there on both Nehru and Gandhi. And on Gandhi to a bigger degree. Gandhi is the one who allowed Rs. 55 crore to be given to the government of Pakistan. The next day, Pakistan triggered the invasion of Kashmir. So many Kashmiris have died as a result of that. If Jinnah had not sent those tribals and the regular Pakistan Army into it, do you think we would have this tragedy? Kashmir would have been Indian or independent or a princely state where the Kashmiris would have decided what they wanted. Jinnah didn't want that and Kashmiris suffered. It is surprising that Kashmiris don't hold him responsible for their pain.

Q: Perhaps, because India has caused Kashmiri Muslims graver political injustice. No?

India has made catastrophic errors of judgment in Kashmir, right from the time when the United Nations Security Council resolutions demanded that Pakistan should withdraw all its Army and irregulars from all territories of Jammu and Kashmir, which is what India wanted. Yet that resolution subsequently started getting weaker after repeated vetoes by the USSR. If you notice the Pakistan movement, Kashmir was not a place where people were saying 'leke rahenge Pakistan, haath mein lota, muuh mein paan'. There were no pro-Pakistan slogans there. Frontier and Kashmir were not pro-Pakistan. They were led by Muslims who were more Muslim than Jinnah could ever be in a hundred lifetimes. They were pious people, Indian nationalists, dedicated to their supporters and both were betrayed by India. So India does not get scot-free. India's hands are bloody as well. But where as India's hands are bloody because of mistakes and errors of judgment, Pakistan's glee in making India bleed is a thought of evil. It is out of hatred.

Q: Does India-Pakistan relationship have a future?

If India-Pakistan relationship has a future, then where is the need of Pakistan? We already had a relationship. We were living in the same cities next-door to each other, especially in Punjab and Kashmir, where people didn't make friends based on religion. There were no segregated ghettos in Lahore which said Muslim quarter or a Hindu quarter. Kishen Nagar or the old city Lahore, the homes were next to each other. So if that is the point, then Pakistan ought to admit that they made a mistake. The day they say they made a mistake, the problem is resolved.

India does not want to invade Pakistan, nobody wishes to invade anyone. It is Pakistanis who have the notion that we have the first strike capability and we can drop a bomb and we are not going to sign no first use. Why? It is Pakistan that says that Afghanistan should be subjugated to our colonial rule rather than let the Kabul have its own foreign policy and independent relations with New Delhi. By all accounts, Pakistan's ruling establishment, the civilian-military establishment is a rogue element that is playing the most vicious dangerous game after the cold war and putting the entire subcontinent at the brink of a nuclear catastrophe. Why can't Pakistan say 'no first use policy'?

If Pakistan becomes a loose confederation of its federating units where the interests of the federating units, not the interests of its military-industrial complex, is legitimate, , where the native languages are allowed, and cultures and customs are allowed to flourish, rather than be dictated by Gulf-Arab states as to what is right and what is wrong, then, of course India and Pakistan can live as states and the past can be forgotten. We will be next-door neighbors like anyone else.

Q: Are you a self-hating Muslim?

No, but if there is something wrong that the Muslims do, why would I be constrained in telling them? Do you think the track record of Muslim leadership is anything to be proud of? Should I be proud of what happened at Jamia? Should I be proud of what's happening with the Syrians? Should I be proud of the Saudis? Tell me who to be proud of? What I am saying is that there is a scarcity of dignified, secular, liberal Muslims who are willing to be honest. If my honesty leads me to be accused of being an Uncle Tom or a self-hating Muslim, I am quite comfortable with that.


My religion commands me to speak the truth and respect that truth even if it hurts you or your family and Quran is specific on that. If that is my fate, what would be my interest? My interest is the betterment of the Muslim people. I like to see them as philosophers, car drivers, the sculptors, and the dancers and the musicians, who the Muslims were during the era of rationalist movement in Baghdad.


Share your views

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Fwd: What the Dr Ambedkar wrote of Islam


In his book, "Pakistan or the Partition of India", towards the end of Chapter 4, Ambedkar writes,

"The Muslim invaders, no doubt, came to India singing a hymn of hate against the Hindus. … Its (Islam's) growth is so thick in Northern India that the remnants of Hindu and Buddhist culture are just shrubs. Even the Sikh axe could not fell this oak. Sikhs, no doubt , became the political masters of Northern India, but they did not gain back Northern India to that spiritual and cultural unity by which it was bound to the rest of India before HsuanTsang."
 
It is interesting to note that despite his views on casteism in Hinduism, Ambedkar saw Hinduism, Buddhism and Sikhism as ONE Indian culture, at the same time, categorically calling Islam an alien culture. In chapter 6 of the same book, he writes,

"From a spiritual point of view, Hindus and Musalmans are not merely two classes or two sects such as Protestants and Catholics or Shaivas and Vaishnavas. They are two distinct species... For them Divinity is divided and with the division of Divinity their humanity is divided and with the division of humanity they must remain divided. There is nothing to bring them in one bosom."
Ambedkar had unequivocally advocated for a population exchange in case of division. Hindus and Sikhs from Pakistan come to India, and Muslims from India, got to Pakistan. In fact, both Sawarkar and RSS were trying to keep India undivided, but Ambedkar, had other views which he articulated in Chapter 6 of the same book. Some of these observations can be in sync with the reality today.

 

"That the transfer of minorities is the only lasting remedy for communal peace is beyond doubt. .. there is no reason to suppose that what they did cannot be accomplished by Indians. After all, the population involved is inconsiderable and because some obstacles require to be removed, it would be the height of folly to give up so sure a way to communal peace... The only way to make Hindustan homogeneous is to arrange for exchange of population. Until that is done, it must be admitted that even with the creation of Pakistan, the problem of majority vs. minority will remain in Hindustan as before and will continue to produce disharmony in the body politic of Hindustan."

Ambedkar, in the same book, has severely criticized Gandhi for his duplicity and double standards he adopted on Hindu killings v/s muslim killings. He writes-

 "But Mr. Gandhi has never protested against such murders. Not only have the Musalmans not condemned these outrages but even Mr. Gandhi has never called upon the leading Muslims to condemn them. He has kept silent over them. Such an attitude can be explained only on the ground that Mr. Gandhi was anxious to preserve Hindu-Moslem unity and did not mind the murders of a few Hindus, if it could be achieved by sacrificing their lives. This attitude to excuse the Muslims any wrong, lest it should injure the cause of unity, is well illustrated by what Mr. Gandhi had to say in the matter of the Mopla riots. The blood-curdling atrocities committed by the Moplas in Malabar against the Hindus were indescribable. All over Southern India, a wave of horrified feeling had spread among the Hindus of every shade of opinion, which was intensified when certain Khilafat leaders were so misguided as to pass resolutions of " congratulations to the Moplas on the brave fight they were conducting for the sake of religion". Any person could have said that this was too heavy a price for Hindu-Moslem unity. But Mr. Gandhi was so much obsessed by the necessity of establishing Hindu-Moslem unity that he was prepared to make light of the doings of the Moplas and the Khilafats who were congratulating them. He spoke of the Moplas as the "brave God-fearing Moplas who were fighting for what they consider as religion and in a manner which they consider as religious ".


And, while Ambedkar later renounced Hinduism due to caste system, he has elaborated how Islam too had an elaborate caste system (again in practice, even though Quran speaks against any division in Islam as an evil).

"Islam speaks of brotherhood. Everybody infers that Islam must be free from slavery and caste. Regarding slavery nothing needs to be said. It stands abolished now by law. But while it existed much of its support was derived from Islam and Islamic countries… The existence of these evils among the Muslims is distressing enough. But far more distressing is the fact that there is no organized movement of social reform among the Musalmans of India on a scale sufficient to bring about their eradication. The Hindus have their social evils. But there is this relieving feature about them—namely, that some of them are conscious of their existence and a few of them are actively agitating for their removal. The Muslims, on the other hand, do not realize that they are evils and consequently do not agitate for their removal. Indeed, they oppose any change in their existing practices.
 It is noteworthy that the "Muslims opposed the Child-Marriage Bill brought in the Central Assembly in 1930, whereby the age for marriage of a girl was raised to 14 and of a boy to 18 on the ground that it was opposed to the Muslim canon law. Not only did they oppose the bill at every stage but that when it became law they started a campaign of Civil Disobedience against that Act. Fortunately the Civil Disobedience campaign of the Muslims against the Act did not swell and was submerged in the Congress Civil Disobedience campaign which synchronized with it. But the campaign only proves how strongly the Muslims are opposed to social reform."


He further writes, "Having been taught that outside Islam there can be no safety; outside its law no truth and outside its spiritual message there is no happiness, the Muslim has become incapable of conceiving any other condition than his own, any other mode of thought than the Islamic thought. He firmly believes that he has arrived at an unequalled pitch of perfection; that he is the sole possessor of true faith, of the true doctrine, the true wisdom ; that he alone is in possession of the truth—no relative truth subject to revision, but absolute truth."

And, Ambedkar also writes, "The third thing that is noticeable is the adoption by the Muslims of the gangster's method in politics. The riots are a sufficient indication that gangsterism has become a settled part of their strategy in politics. .. So long as the Muslims were the aggressors, the Hindus were passive, and in the conflict they suffered more than the Muslims did. But this is no longer true. The Hindus have learned to retaliate and no longer feel any compunction in knifing a Musalman. This spirit of retaliation bids fair to produce the ugly spectacle of gangsterism against gangsterism."


In chapter 12, he observes, "Among the tenets one that calls for notice is the tenet of Islam which says that in a country which is not under Muslim rule wherever there is a conflict between Muslim law and the law of the land, the former must prevail over the latter and a Muslim will be justified in obeying the Muslim law and defying the law of the land."

"Islam is a close corporation and the distinction that it makes between Muslims and non-Muslims is a very real, very positive and very alienating distinction. The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity. ...
In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India."


It is for the Muslim scholars to rebut or validate what Ambedkar has written about Islam. But, the secular politicians, who invoke Ambedkar in everything relating to Dalit politics, and have formed a Dalit-Muslim alliance, should also clarify if they agree to what Ambedkar has written.

<pakistan.pdf>

Fwd: ‘Purushottama Sanman’ to farmers practicing organic farming


RSS Sarakaryavah presents the 'Purushottama Sanman' to farmers practicing organic farming

April 15th, 2013, 12:17 am

The only way to realize 'SujalamSuphalam' is going 'Organic'

April 10th, Theerthahalli: Excessive usage of chemicals is turning the lands poisonous. To revive such lands, 'Go Raksha',

safeguardi the cow is indispensable said JayaramPatidara, a progressive farmer from Madhya Pradesh.

RSS General Secretary Suresh Bhaiyyaji Joshi facilitated Madhya Pradesh's Organic Farmer Jayaram Patidar at Theerthahalli, Karnataka on April-10-2013.

 

Accepting the 'PurushottamaSanman', an award instituted by the agriculture research foundation of Kuruvalli  inthe name of the sage of farmingShri.PurushottamaRai,, he said that we should grow all food products needed in our daily life using the organic farming methods and thus aim to become self-reliant.

"Many who meet me ask what the aim of my life is. I have not got an answer to his till date. But it is clear that I have found peace through hard work and rendering service to the cow. Since I started serving the cow and practicing organic farming from the last 5 years, neither me nor any of my family members have been to a hospital or run errands to the bank", he explained.

 he further said that through multiple usage of products based on cattle produce and 'panchagavya'(cowpathy), one can become self-reliant in maintaining the 'go shala' and rearing of cattle. "I have proven and demonstrated this in the Shri Krishna Balarama Goshala which is in my native city of Chakaroda", he told.

Giving his blessing on the occasion, VishveshwaraTheertha Swamiji of Pejawar Math said that the cow should have been our national animal. He opined that by making the Tiger our national animal, violent attitudeis increasing in people.

Environmental campaign started in those days when BhagwanShri Krishna defeated the serpent Kalinga( Kaliya Nag कालिया नाग ) in the Yamuna River. Today the Kalinga has been replaced by factories. The condition today is such that people have to be told not to use river water as it has become poisonous, he said.

Speaking on the occasion after presenting the awards to the achievers in organic farming , General Secretary of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh Suresh Joshi said that the 5-years plans that were implemented without knowing the true spirit of Bharat is the reason for the sad state of our villages today.He further stated that on the occasion of the 'Green Revolution' completing 50 years, it is the right time to review the pros and cons of the five years plans.

We tried to bring about a green revolution by excessive use of Hybrid breeds and use of chemicals but in the process lost many original ideas of our indigenous farming techniques. Farmers have become desperate today due to the directionless agricultural policies. Many insects that supplemented farming were lost due to the use of insecticides. Due to this the government is now trying to enforce plans for deployment on insects, he rued.

He opined that to bring back the farmers who have lost direction to the right path, there has to be an increase in organic farmers like Jayaram and PurushottamRai.

Chairman of the Agriculture Research Foundation Subbarao and trustees A.S.Anand and V.K.Arunkumar were present on the occasion.

JayaramaPatidar, who was felicitated on the occasion, and his family were brought onto the stage in a decorated bullock cart. The procession started at the GayatriMandir, passed through Kuvempu circle andreached the Suvarna Sahakara Bhavan.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Fwd: પરબની પ્રેરણા (સત્ય ઘટના) – અમૃત મોરારજી


મુંબઈમાં ઠંડા પીણાં અને મિનરલ વૉટરની કંપનીઓના માલિક વસંતલાલ શેઠ પોતાની વાનમાં નાના ગામડામાં આવી રહ્યા છે. એમના વતનના ફાર્મ હાઉસ 'વસંત વિહાર'માં આજે એક રાત રોકાવાના છે. શેઠ વર્ષમાં એકાદ વાર ગામમાં આવે. રાત્રીરોકાણ કરી સવારે ચાલ્યા જાય.

આજે ઉનાળાની કાળઝાળ ગરમી છે. વાનમાં બેઠેલા સૌને તરસ લાગી છે. 'વસંત વિહાર' હજુ લગભગ સાતેક કિલોમીટર દૂર છે. વાનમાં લાવવામાં આવેલ તમામ ઠંડાં પીણાં અને મિનરલ વૉટરની બાટલીઓ પીવાઈને પૂરી થઈ ગયેલ છે. પાણી વિના મિનિટ પણ રહી શકાય એમ નથી, પણ પાણી મળી શકે એમ નથી. માર્ગની બંને બાજુ બસ વગડો જ છે. ચારેક કિલોમીટર વાન આગળ વધી પછી અચાનક એક નાના સરખા પરબનાં દર્શન થતાં વાન ત્યાં ઊભી રાખી સૌએ પરબના મટકાનું ઠંડું પાણી પી તરસ ભાંગી. શેઠે રૂપિયા પાંચસોની નોટ પરબનું પાણી પાનાર વૃદ્ધા સામે ધરી.
'
ના, પૈસા ના જોઈએ. મૃત્યુ પામેલા મારા યુવાન પુત્રના આત્માની શાંતિ માટે ઉનાળામાં પરબ માંડી મફત પાણી પીવડાવું છું. ગરીબ વિધવા છું. ગામમાં પાણીની બહુ જ તંગી છે, પણ આ સિવાય હું કંઈ કરી શકું એમ નથી.' વૃદ્ધાએ પૈસા લેવાની ના પાડતાં કહ્યું.

શેઠ વાન આગળ હંકારી ગયા, પણ આ ઘટનાની એમના મન પર ઘણી જ અસર થઈ. એક વૃદ્ધ ગરીબ વિધવા લોકોને પરબ માંડી મફત પાણી પીવડાવે અને હું ઠંડાં પીણાં અને મિનરલ વૉટરની કંપનીઓનો કરોડપતિ શેઠ પોતાના ગામ માટે પાણીની કોઈ વ્યવસ્થા નથી કરી શકતો ? આ વિચારથી શેઠ વસંતલાલ દુઃખી થઈ ગયા. વસંતલાલે ગામમાં પાણીની યોજના કરવા મનમાં પાકો નિર્ણય કરી લીધો.

આજે મોડી રાત્રે બાર વાગ્યા પછી 'વસંત વિહાર' ફાર્મ હાઉસમાં ગામના સરપંચ રમણલાલ, યુવાન સામાજિક કાર્યકર અને શિક્ષક ભાવેશ સાથે શેઠ વસંતલાલની વાતચીત શરૂ થઈ.
'
આ ભાવેશ મુંબઈમાં ચાળીસ હજારની નોકરી છોડી ગામમાં જનસેવા અને ગામકલ્યાણનાં કામ કરવા આવ્યો છે. અહીં છ હજારની શિક્ષકની નોકરી કરે છે અને ગામમાં સામાજિક તેમ જ જનકલ્યાણનાં કામો કરે છે.' એમ સરપંચ રમણલાલે કહ્યું.
'
ધન્યવાદ ભાવેશને. ગામને અને દેશને આજે આવા જ યુવાનોની જરૂર છે.' શેઠ વસંતલાલે કહ્યું.
'
શેઠ, આ ગામને સૌથી મોટી તકલીફ પાણીની છે. ચાર કિલોમીટર દૂર આવેલી નદી સુધી ગામલોકોએ પાણી ભરવા જવું પડે છે. અમારી ઈચ્છા એ નદીમાંથી પાણી ગામમાં લાવવાની છે. તે માટે ચાર કિલોમીટર લાંબી પાઈપલાઈન નાખી મોટું જળાશય બનાવવું પડે. એક કરોડ દસ લાખનો ખર્ચ થવા સંભવ છે. સરકાર આગળ રજૂઆત કરી છે, પણ વાત આગળ વધતી નથી.' ભાવેશે ગામમાં પાણીની તકલીફની વાત કરતાં કહ્યું.
'
એમાં હવે સરકારી મદદની શી જરૂર, ભાવેશ ?' વસંતલાલે પ્રશ્ન કરતાં કહ્યું.
'
પણ શેઠ, આટલી મોટી રકમ લાવવી ક્યાંથી ?' ભાવેશે પ્રશ્ન કર્યો.

'જો ગામની એક વૃદ્ધ ગરીબ વિધવા ઉનાળામાં પરબ માંડી ગામલોકોને મફત પાણી પીવડાવતી હોય તો હું ઠંડા પીણાં અને મિનરલ વૉટરની કંપનીનો માલિક કરોડપતિ શેઠ મારા વતન-ગામમાં એક જળાશય ન બનાવી શકું ?' શેઠે વધુ એક પ્રશ્ન પૂછતાં કહ્યું.
'
તો શેઠ તમો અમારા ભગવાન.' સરપંચ રમણલાલે કહ્યું.
'
દાન જરૂરતમંદો પ્રત્યે દાનવીરનું એક સામાન્ય અને સામાજિક કર્તવ્ય છે. દાન કરવાથી માનવ ભગવાન સમાન ન ગણાય. ચાલો તમે શરૂ કરો જળાશય બનાવવાનું કામ. તમામ ખર્ચ અને બીજી મદદ મારા તરફથી મળશે. આ લો દસ કોરા ચેક. ભાવેશ અને રમણલાલ, મને તમારા પર પૂરો વિશ્વાસ છે.' શેઠે પોતાની સહીવાળા કોરા ચેકો આપતાં કહ્યું. અને માત્ર એક જ વર્ષમાં સૌના સહકારથી ગામમાં પાણીથી ભરપૂર જળાશય બની ગયું. ગરીબ-વૃદ્ધ વિધવાના પરબની પ્રેરણાથી બનેલા આ જળાશયનું નામ શેઠના કહેવાથી વૃદ્ધાના નામ પરથી 'ગંગા-જળાશય' રાખવામાં આવ્યું. ('જન્મભૂમિ પ્રવાસી'માંથી સાભાર.)


 

 



Monday, April 15, 2013

Bali state of Indonesia, a secular country


 

Bali is a state of Indonesia, a secular country with the biggest Muslim population in the world. But the majority in the state of Bali, over 93 %, are Hindus. Bali is home to 4.22 million Hindus whose ancestors had to flee from other islands of Indonesia, after the great Indonesian Hindu Empire Majapahit was defeated and most of Indonesia was converted to Islam. Here are some interesting facts about Bali that every Indian Hindu must know.


1. Nyepi day, a day of total silence (mauna) once a year, when even the Ngurah Rai International Airport of Denpasar is closed from 6 am to 6 am. No cars, no traffic, no entertainment, no TV. Sit in the house, do contemplation, do prayers. Can we introduce that Nyepi Day in our noisy country?

2. The culture of Bali was begun by the Rishis of India, whose names are no longer taught in the schools of India but which are common in the schools of Bali—Markandeya, Bharadwaja, Agastya - the names we hear in the Puranas but they are part of the way the history of Bali is taught in the schools of Bali. How many Rishis can you name? Do you remember any one of the 402 names of the Rishis and Rishikas (female Rishis) from the Rig Veda (the most ancient and most sacred text of Hinduism), which are our ancestors and the forming fathers of our religion – Vaidika Sanatana Dharma?

3. The national Balinese dress for both, men and women, girls and boys, is Dhoti. No one can enter a temple without wearing a Dhoti. Except in some parts of South India, Dhoti is laughed at in India today. Why are we so ashamed of our heritage? Even most Indian priests change their dress after they are finished with the worship because they feel ashamed in a Dhoti??

4. The social, economic and political system of Bali is based on the principle of tri-hita-karana…three benevolent, beneficent principles— that every human being has three aspects …the duty, the relationship that we have with God [Parahyangan]; the relationship that we have with human beings [Pawongan]; and the relationship that we have with nature [Palemahan] and these are the three principles on which the entire culture of Bali is built. This was all established by the Rishis whose names are just about forgotten in India which are taught in the schools of Bali.

5. Trikala Sandhya (Sun worship three times a day) is practiced in every Balinese school. The Gayatri Mantra is recited by every Balinese school child three times a day. Many of the local radio stations also relay Trikala Sandhya three times a day. Can we even think of introducing something like this to our schools in India? How many Indian Hindus are aware of their duty of Trikala Sandhya? It is as central to our religion as the 5 times Namaz is to Islam, yet?

6. In the year 1011 AD, at a place which is now known as Purasamantiga… there was the first interreligious conference of three religions: Shaiva Agama, Bauddha Agama and Baliyaga, the traditional pre-Buddhist, pre-Hindu, Balinese religion. The scholars and the leaders sat down and worked out a system by which the three religions should work together and exchange forms with each other and that is the religion of Bali today.

7. In Bali every priest is paid by the government. Despite the fact that Indonesia is a secular country with the biggest Muslim population in the world, the priest of every religion is paid by the government so every religion is supported by the government. That is the Indonesian form of secularism. Can we even think of this in India?

8. The national motto of Indonesia "Bhinneka Tunggal Ika. One is many, many is one." is inspired by an Indonesian Hindu scripture Sutasoma Kakavin. The complete quotation is as follows - "It is said that the well known Buddha and Shiva are two different substances; they are indeed different, yet how is it possible to recognize their difference in a glance, since the truth of Buddha and the truth of Shiva are one? They may be different, but they are of the same kind, as there is no duality in truth." Why can't we have "Ekam Sad Vipra Bahudha Vadanti" (The truth is one, but the wise express it in various ways – Rig Veda) as our national motto?

9. Bali is one of the world's most prominent rice growers. Every farm has a temple dedicated to Shri Devi and Bhu Devi (Lakmi the Goddess of wealth and mother earth - the two divinities that stand on the either of side of Tirupati Bala ji in India). No farmer will perform his agricultural duties without first making offerings to Shri Devi and Bhu Devi. That is called culture, that SubakSystem. The agricultural and water irrigation plan for the entire country was charted in the 9th Century. The priests of a particular water temple still control this irrigation plan. And some World Bank or United Nations scientist did a computer model that would be ideal for Bali. And when they brought the model the Balinese said 'we have been practicing this since the 9th century. What are you bringing here?' And I don't know how many million dollars these WTO, these World Bank people, United Nations people, spent on creating that chart which was already created in the 9th century without any computers…. and that Subak System still continues. Such systems were in place in various parts of the country. Its remnants are still visible here in India. I have visited areas where there is no water for miles due to drought, yet the well at the local temple still provides fresh water.

10. In Bali Hindus still don't read a printed book when they perform Puja (worship). They read from a Lontar, which have traditionally been scripted by hand on palm leaf. When they recite the Ramayana Kakavin…where the book is kept, worship will be performed. There is a special ritual of lifting the sacred book, carrying it in a procession, bringing [it] to a special place, doing the bhumi puja, worshipping the ground there and consecrating the ground, then placing the book there. Then the priest will sit and recite the Ramayana. 

When I was called to Bali it was to teach and preach the Vedic teachings. But I came back with a humble realization that I have to learn more from Bali than I can actually teach them.

Facts according to Swami Veda Bharati, a great master of meditation from the Himalayan Tradition.

 

 

China distorting History for political gains


 

Distorting History for political gains :The communists of China are seeking to recreate the "greater China" of the Qing Dynasty, which was a Manchu, not Han, dynasty

Revanchist China

John Lee

John Lee is a fellow and professor at the Center for International Security Studies, Sydney Universit
http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/greater-china-and-asia-s-sovereignty-disputes-by-john-lee#


* Revanchist meaning_ A usually political policy, as of a nation or an ethnic group, intended to regain lost territory or standing

SYDNEY – In a speech at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, DC, on February 22, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe informed the audience of officials, experts, and journalists that Japan is "back" and will not stand down in its ongoing sovereignty dispute with China over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands. With Chinese provocations on the rise, US President Barack Obama, Abe's host, appealed for calm and restraint on both sides.

This illustration is by Chris Van Es and comes from <a href="http://www.newsart.com">NewsArt.com</a>, and is the property of the NewsArt organization and of its artist. Reproducing this image is a violation of copyright law.Illustration by Chris Van Es

Japan is likely to accede – grudgingly – to America's request, as it remains dependent on its alliance with the US for its security. But it will be much more difficult to persuade China that it should stand down.

China's assertiveness over its sovereignty claim reflects more than a desire to exploit seabed resources, or to gain a widened strategic gateway into the western Pacific. It is also about national renewal and rejuvenation – the core of the Chinese Communist Party's raison d'être. Turning away from a fight with its former occupier and historical rival would be a step backward in this six-decade-long quest.

The idea of Chinese renewal or rejuvenation was popularized by then-Premier Zhao Ziyang in the late 1980's, and frequently promoted by Presidents Jiang Zemin and Hu Jintao. Most recently, incoming President Xi Jinping, visiting the National Museum of China's "Road Toward Renewal" exhibition, pledged to continue the "great renewal of the Chinese nation."

What does "renewal" or "rejuvenation" mean to the Chinese? All nations – great and small – embody a combination of historical fact and myth. In this case, the CCP's view of rejuvenation is built on the belief that the zenith of Chinese power under the Ming and Qing dynasties represents the natural, just, and permanent state of affairs for a 5,000-year-old civilization.

When Mao Zedong took power in 1949, his immediate goal was to re-establish the "greater China" of the Qing Dynasty (1644-1912), insisting that the Manchu-led empire was the permanent and enduring China.

But, while the assault on the Qing Dynasty by foreign powers is a historical fact, the notion that there has been one enduring China struggling against avaricious outsiders across several millennia is false and self-serving.

Mao achieved his goal following the so-called peaceful liberation of the East Turkestan Republic (now Xinjiang) in 1949 and the invasion of Tibet in 1950, which promptly increased China's size by more than one-third.

And every CCP (Chinese Communist Party) leader since has carried forward his vision of a greater China, adjusting and expanding it as the country's power grows. For example, China showed little interest in the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands prior to 1968 – the year a geographical study pointed to vast oil reserves beneath the seabed.

The same can be said for China's growing stridency with respect to its claims in the South China Sea. In 2009, relying heavily on a dubious historical claim, China formally tabled its "nine-dotted line" map to the United Nations Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf, and has since referred to almost all of the South China Sea as being under its "indisputable sovereignty."

Having dominated East and Southeast Asia for all but the last two centuries of the past two millennia, China is chafing at the current US-led regional order of sovereign states, in which even the smallest enjoys the same rights, privileges, and protection as the largest. Modern China has benefited enormously from this arrangement; nonetheless, there is keen resentment that the Chinese civilization-state's vast achievements over several thousand years offer China no special status.

To a people imbued with a deep sense of superior moral worth, historical achievement, and victimization by foreign powers, this state of affairs is unjust and unnatural. It follows that pulling back from any territorial dispute with smaller and inferior states would be seen as a humiliating defeat, rather than a step toward ensuring long-term regional stability.

Moreover, an expanding view of greater China implies that a resolution of the dispute over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands in China's favor would be likely to embolden rather than satisfy its ambitions. Making good on its claim to the South China Sea could be next.

As Obama and Abe forge a common strategy aimed at helping to manage China's rise peacefully, they must understand that China's conception of renewal seeks to resurrect a glorious past, and that this implies revision, not affirmation, of the existing regional order. This means that they will have to limit China's strategic and military options, even if they cannot constrain its ambitions.

Saturday, April 13, 2013

: picture of late margret in HSS makarsankraman Utsav


दान जगत् का प्रकृत धर्म है, मनुज व्यर्थ डरता है, एक रोज तो हमें स्वयं सब कुछ देना पड़ता है। बचते वही समय पर जो सर्वस्व दान करते हैं, ऋतु का ज्ञान नहीं जिनको, वे देकर भी मरते हैं।